Best Crib Mattress Review 2017- Experts Guide

Choosing the best crib mattress for your kid goes beyond comfort. You need a mattress that offers optimal safety for best crib mattressyour kid. However, to ensure that it’s safe you should check its firmness. What procedure should one use to check for firmness? Worry not, I am going to give a detailed guide on how to undertake the task.

Nevertheless making such analyses and coming up with the best choice can be daunting at times. We reviewed over 20 crib mattresses and selected the top 10 best crib mattresses for your kid based on many factors which we will discuss shortly.

Ok, without wasting much time let us move straight to our top 10 crib mattress

Top 10 Best Crib Mattresses For Kids

NameWeight (Pounds)Materials UsedDimensions (Inches) 
Newton Crib Mattress11Food grade polymer
Polyester cover
28 x 3.5 x 52 Check Price
Moonlight Slumber Crib15.8Cotton cover27.5 x 52 x 5 Check Price
Colgate Classica Crib Mattress9.4Infused plant oils
Cotton cover
51.7 x 27.5 x 6 Check Price
Safely 1st Heavenly Crib Mattress7.5Fiber
Vinyl cover
52.5 x 27.5 x 5.5 Check Price
Naturepedic Organic Crib20Organic cotton cover
Polyethylene cover
52 x 27.8 x 6 Check Price
Sealy Soybean Crib Mattress8.373 % foam
22% soybean oil
51.6 x 27.2 x 5 Check Price
Simmon Beautyrest26Inner foam
Woven cover
52 x 27.5 x 6 Check Price
Milliard Hypoallergenic Mattress10Polyester Cover52 x 27.5 x 5.5 Check Price
Kolcraft Crib Mattress11.6Vinyl cover
51.6 x 27.2 x 5 Check Price
Dream On Me Crib MattrssVinyl mattress cover
Interwoven coils
52 x 27 x 6 Check Price

1. Newton woveinare Crib Mattress- Best Crib Mattress in Terms of Safety
Newtpn crib mattress

For a crib mattress to be among the best it ought to be extremely safe for use by infants. Would you buy a crib mattress that endangers your child’s life? Of course, the answer is an outstanding No!! Honestly, some factors can be compromised but safety remains paramount when it comes to choosing the best crib mattress for your kid.


However, Newton Company has seamlessly designed newton crib mattress without compromising on any single feature.  Safety, comfort, durability and ease of washability were the top factors in mind during the design of Newton Woveinare crib mattress.

Description of Newton Woveinare
Ease of Cleaning
Comfort & Flexibility


Newton crib mattress is perfect for your kid. It comes at a cost effective price. Due to the safety of this crib, it is recommended by pediatricians as one of the best organic cribs that should be used by infants.

  • It allows breathability hence prevents suffocation and overheating of infants at night.
  • The cover can be easily removed and washed
  • It is free of any allergenic substances or toxic chemicals
  • It is also extremely comfortable and cozy
  • It is moderately priced

2. Moonlight Slumber Little Dreamer Dual Firmness Crib Mattress – Best Mattress For Infants & Toddlers

Best crib for toddlers
When I heard of this mattress, I was really curious to know more about it. On further investigation, my curiosity was satisfied by its unique nature. Moonlight Slumber Little Dreamer Dual Firmness Crib Mattress does not only bring joy to your child but it is more of a gift. It surprises me for the fact that it can be used for both infants and toddlers. I am sure that the first time parents cannot regret having one.

It surprises me for the fact that it can be used for both infants and toddlers. I am sure that the first time parents cannot regret having one.



Features of Moonlight Crib Mattress
Air Circulation

Moonlight Slumber Little Dreamer Dual Firmness Crib Mattress can fit in various crib beds and so there is no need to worry much about the crib bed you have. Crib sheets are normally used for this type of mattress.

I will be quick to say that these mattresses have no smell except the obvious one that that comes with its newness. However, it goes away after some time. The mattress is bound to make creepy noises but they are not that disturbing. All in all, Moonlight Slumber Little Dreamer Dual Firmness Crib Mattress is a great mattress for its affordable price.


  • Affordable
  • Have two sides for infants and toddlers
  • Waterproof matress cover
  • Non-toxic and non-allergenic
  • Firm, durable and comfortable
  • It makes creepy noises

3. Colgate Classica Crib Mattress- Best Eco-friendly Crib Mattress

Colgate crib mattress
Are you looking for an eco-friendly mattress? A crib that is free from toxic emissions and allergic chemicals? If so, then look no further. When somebody mentions an environmental friendly mattress I always think of Colgate Classica. It is as well seamlessly designed to accommodate the sleep needs of both an infant and a toddler.

What sets Colgate Classica apart from other crib mattresses?

Ok, let’s go systemically and look at the individual features of this awesome crib.


Colgate Crib Mattress Review
Comfort & Firmness
Composition & Design


In conclusion, this crib is perfect for anyone who is looking for an eco-friendly mattress either for an infant or toddler. It provides maximum safety and comfort that is needed. All these features come at a quiet fair price.

  • It has a dual firmness surface
  • It is made from plant oils which are eco-friendly
  • The mattress cover is non-removable

4. Safely 1st Heavenly Dreams Crib Mattress – Best Mattress For Kids

Safety 1st Heavenly Dreams Crib Mattress is the mattress of choice for the comfort of your child. Kids too need a heavenly sleep and you can always tell if they have one or not. This is by observing their morning mood. When my aunt told me of this mattress, I always wanted to share the story with other parents. Now I got the best opportunity ever.

When my aunt told me of this mattress, I always wanted to share the story with other parents. Now I got the best opportunity ever.

Safely Heavenly Crib Mattress Review
Design & Dimensions
Washability Properties


Compliance with Safety Regulations
In the event that your child is very playful or naughty, they might from time to time try to squeeze their hands through the mattress corners adjacent to the bed corners. I am pleased to say that the mattress has round corners which fit perfectly on the bed corners allowing no space.

Safety 1st Heavenly Dreams Crib Mattresses are affordable and their price cannot be compared to the quality sleep they offer.

It is unfortunate that these mattresses do not fit a twin crib sheet but only fits a regular crib sheet. If your child tosses in bed you might hear some noises from the mattress but they are not disturbing as such.

  • Affordable
  • Firm
  • Durable
  • Allergen free
  • Odour free
  • Have a vinyl cover that is water proof
  • Makes creeping noises

5. Naturepedic Organic Dual Firm Crib Mattress – Best Organic Crib Mattress

As the name goes by, “nature”-pedic is an absolutely organic crib mattress. It is made of organic substances which are completely free form any chemicals. It is a good choice to consider if you need a crib mattress made from natural fabric for your kid.

It may be of interest to know what constitutes Naturepedic crib mattress. Ok, to cover that lets move straight to its design and composition.

Naturepedic Crib Mattress Review
Constitution & Design
Comfort & hygiene


Flammability & chemical test


In conclusion, naturepedic organic crib mattress comes at a slightly higher price compared to other crib mattresses because it is made using organic materials. However, the excellent fabric is cost effective in comparison to the quality. Anyone looking for a high quality, durable and an organic crib mattress should always go for it.

  • It is constituted of 100 % cotton therefore, it is an organic crib
  • There is a waterproof cover that makes it easy to clean
  • It has a dual firm design that makes it possible to be used by both toddlers and infants
  • It has a slight odour on the first few days of buying

6. Sealy Soybean Foam Crib Mattress

Soybean crib mattress is one of the best mattress when it comes to firmness and comfort. Actually, for you information, it was voted the best in the women choice awards. When you are looking for a quality mattress for your new born you ought to look on a mattress that is firm and does not sag. Indeed, soybean crib is among the best. Were it not for the fact it has a non-natural mattress cover it would have been my number one choice.

Why buy soybean crib? It is a crib mattress with excellent comfort, durability and comes with a waterproof cover.

Ok, without wasting much time let’s look at the quality features of Sealy crib mattress.

Sealy Soybean Crib Mattress Review
Design & Dimensions
Durability & cleanliness
Flexibility & Comfort


In conclusion, Sealy soybean crib mattress comes with quality features at a very fair price. In comparison to its features the price is really fair. However, it is a bit highly priced compared to other crib mattresses. Nevertheless, they can never much the excellent features of crib mattress.

  • It has a waterproof cover
  • Made of highly firm foam core
  • It is made of soybean oil
  • Can be easily cleaned
  • It has a plastic cover

7. Simmons Beautyrest Crib Mattress

Beautyrest is an awesome crib mattress that ensures optimal comfort and safety during a night sleep. This crib mattress is manufactured in the United States of America by Simmons Company. It is one of the leading companies in USA that utilizes latest mattress technology to manufacture high quality and comfy sleep products. I always remember the cozy feel and perfect smooth design when I hear somebody mentioning Simmons Beautyrest.

In just a few minutes I will tell you the exclusive features of Simmons crib mattress in a categorical order.

Simmons Beautyrest Crib Mattress Review
Comfort & Design





In conclusion, Simmons Beautyrest crib mattress is a good choice if you are looking for a comfortable and durable mattress. It comes with awesome design and features at an economical price.

  • It has pocketed coil springs for stability and comfort
  • It has a natural wrap that protects it against fire.
  • It is has no chemicals infused in it
  • It is a little bit heavy. This crib mattress has a weight of 26 pounds.

8. Milliard Hypoallergenic Crib Mattress

Do you need a mattress with maximum safety and comfort for you kid? Are you looking for a crib that will provide a good night sleep with a cozy feel on lying on it? Ok, if that’s the case then look no further. Milliard is a real deal! Milliard crib mattress is perfectly designed ensuring maximum durability, firmness and hygiene. Its classy design and feel always makes this mattress to be among my top pick any day.

Now, the question comes in. What makes milliard crib mattress unique or stand out from the rest?

We reviewed and analyzed each feature individually and wrote a detailed review.

Milliard Crib Mattress Review
Design and dimensions


The major drawback milliard crib is that it smells on the first week of buying. However, the odor absolutely goes away after one week. To hasten the process, you can leave it in open air for a few hours.

To sum it up, milliard mattress comes with credible features and is also cost friendly. It is perfect for kids who are hypersensitive to allergens, dust or are asthmatic.

  • Hypoallergenic
  • Comfortable
  • Has a waterproof cover
  • It has a slight odor

9. Kolcraft Pure Therapeutic 150 Crib Mattress – Best Crib Mattress For a Limited Budget

When I am looking for a cost effective and relatively comfortable crib mattress I will always go for this mattress. Kolcraft crib mattress is uniquely designed to give maximum safety and comfort for your kid. It also comes with high quality premium coils and cover that are not found in other normal mattresses.

How is safety and comfort of kolcraft made possible? Ok, let me analyze the features of this crib mattress systematically.

Kolcraft Crib Mattress Review
Comfort and safety






One thing I did not like is that the kolcraft mattress cover produces sounds at night when a kid makes movements in the bed. The sound may reduce the comfort of this mattress and even make your kid to wake up at night.


Anyone who is on a limited budget and needs a relatively comfortable crib mattress this should be your number one choice. Not expect it to be the best as there is a saying which claims you get what you pay for!!

10. Dream On Me Spring Crib Mattress

As the name suggest Dream crib mattress is made of springs that ensures optimal comfort and support for your kid. The crib is elegantly designed to give a nice look and a comfortable rest.

The most important issue, is that all these awesome features comes at a very friendly price in comparison with other crib mattresses. Ok, let me move into the detailed features regarding the design and its other superb benefits.

Dream Spring Crib Mattress Review





Bad side

Just like the Kolcraft, its mattress cover frequently produces sounds at night. This may make your kid uncomfortable at night. The sounds at times prevents your kid from having a restful sleep especially if your kid makes frequent movements at night. Solution: Buying a crib mattress cover which is made of organic material I.e. cotton will solve the issue.


Dream on me crib mattresses is one of the cost effective mattress to buy when you are on a limited budget. It has almost all the premium features.

  • It has an antibacterial and waterproof cover
  • Comfortable
  • It has a firm support surface due to the 80 interwoven coils
  • The mattress cover is noisy when one makes movements

Buyers Guide For Choosing The Best Crib Mattress in 2017

Knowing the factors that you should look at when selecting the best suited crib mattress for your baby is vital. Currently, there are many mattresses for babies in the market. Consequently, it becomes a hard task, especially when you have no idea on the factors to look at. I remember my older cousin had a hard time when selecting a crib mattress for her newborn. This made be to be curious and ultimately research more on the features that high quality mattresses should possess.

Selecting the most appropriate crib mattress for your baby is important. This is because kids are highly susceptible to infection and also have a risk of suffocation. Therefore, safety of your kid should always be the top factor in mind when selecting a crib mattress.

Ok, without giving much stories let us look at factors that one ought to consider.


You should look for a firm mattress. However, it should not be excessively hard since it will make your kid uncomfortable. A firm surface is essential for your child’s growth since it strengthens the joints and muscles. Additionally, Consumer product safety commission advocates for a firm surface which prevents cases of suffocation. To test for firmness, you should press your hand on the crib surface and observe if it conforms to the shape of your hand on releasing. If it does not conform, then its firm enough.

Air flow design

Having a crib mattress which has poor air circulation causes overheating. Additionally, it reduces breathability which may suffocate your baby. Therefore, the best crib mattress should have good air flow design to enhance breathability and allow sufficient air circulation. As well, excellent prevents overheating of your kid.

Mattress cover

Having a mattress cover which cannot be cleaned properly increases risk of your kid getting infections. One should look either for a mattress that either can be easily unzipped and washed with water or can be easily wiped. A waterproof cover is also an essential feature in crib mattresses because babies frequently urinate and even poop on themselves.

Meeting the certification standards

A crib mattress that meets all the US certification is a good choice. First a crib mattress should be Green Guard certified which is an indication that it has low rate of chemical emissions which may be toxic. They should also be centipur us certified. The certification is a confirmation that it has been tested for all toxic chemicals and passes all the test. The materials used for manufacture should also be hypoallergenic and free of any flammable and toxic chemicals.


Definitely, the price is one of the factors that cannot be ignored when choosing any mattress. Organic crib mattresses are usually expensive compared to others. However, the materials used to manufacture them are also expensive. Whereas foam mattresses are moderately expensive.


Deciding the best crib mattress depends on the individual needs of each kid. Additionally, it also depends on your budget. For example, if you need a crib mattress for your kid to use both as an infant and toddler, then Newton woveinare, Colgate crib or Moonlight would be a perfect choice depending on your budget.

If you are working on a very tight budget and you need the best crib mattress then Kolcraft or Dream on me crib mattress would be a superb selection.

Parting shot:  Before deciding on the best crib mattress for your baby always analyze the needs of your child and choice based on both the needs and your set budget. 

We will be happy to hear your thoughts

Leave a reply

Register New Account
Reset Password
Compare items
  • Cameras (0)
  • Phones (0)